In recent years, I admit, I’ve read mainly novels – I love the thickness of the books, the way you can immerse yourself in a tale and forget about the world for a bit. But National Short Story Day just before Christmas, and The Guardian’s recent short story podcasts, got me wondering about the genre, and reminded me that there are many short stories that have affected me deeply. They also got me itching to read some more.
Somehow, to write a story that really packs a punch in the space of, say, 1,000 words seems an incredible feat. Ian Rankin has summed the challenge up well. “The best short stories,” he said, “distill all the potency of a novel into a small but heady draught”. Despite this, I often feel that the short story form sits in the shadow of the novel – less well known and less loved.
So I thought I’d celebrate a few of the stories that I’ve loved in the past, and some I’ve only discovered recently. I’d love to hear what your favourites are, too.
1. The first short story that really made an impact with me was Your Shoes by Michele Roberts. I studied it in secondary school and it had such an effect on me that I found myself wanting to have a little weep in class (possibly an over reaction – I don’t know). It’s a monologue from a mother whose daughter has run away from home, and explores themes of loss, blame, conflict and love. The regret and longing of the (somewhat untrustworthy) narrator, and the exaggerated meaning she gives a pair of her daughter’s shoes, makes for an emotional read.
2. The Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe is perhaps one of the best known short stories, and with good reason – the murderous schemings and unusual justifications of the main character stay with you long after you close the book. The narrator is again an untrustworthy one, who insists on sanity after murdering an old man. It’s a dark, compelling read.
3. I only discovered recently that Frank Capra’s film It’s a Wonderful Life is actually based on a book, a short story called The Greatest Gift by Philip van Doren Stern. Even if you’ve seen the film (which most people probably have), it’s well worth having a gander at the original text – there’s something quite beautiful about the simplistic way it’s written.
4. The Doll’s House, by Katherine Mansfield, is the story Margaret Drabble chose to read for The Guardian short story podcast, and it’s great – a sharp depiction of the difficulties and injustices of social heirarcies among children and adults. The tale made me think how little I thought about the consequences of my actions when I was younger.
5. Oscar Wilde’s The Canterville Ghost is a fun re-imagining of the ghost story genre, in which an American family buy an old and haunted property in Britain, despite being warned of the numerous mishaps and deaths that have taken place there. But neither the family nor the resident ghost act as you would expect them to and, following a series of comical meetings and events, it becomes unclear who is terrorising who.